I can't believe that XM Radio is complaining about software that acts like TiVo for the service. Its even more ridiculous because the tuner this guy uses came with a USB interface and a XM supplied SDK. What did XM really think people were going to do with this SDK? Even more egregious is their tone in the article:
"We remain concerned about any devices or software that permit listeners to transform a broadcast into a music library," RIAA spokesman Jonathan Lamy said.
It's a friggin' tape recorder or VCR. And how about this gem:
XM Satellite Radio Holdings said it was concerned about the software, based on a description of its features.
"That's a product that's not authorized by XM," Chance Patterson, vice president of corporate affairs, told Reuters last week.
"That program is something we don't condone ... It's our expectation they will be shut down," he added. "We're also researching any potential legal violations."
Let me get this straight. They haven't seen the software yet, but they are sure that its illegal and they have sent in all the lawyers to find something wrong with it. Way to go XM, go insult and alienate your customers and encourage them not to make your product more useful.
Existance of this product makes me want XM more...knowledge that XM is being idiotic at the least, and evil at the extreme makes me want XM less. So its really a wash now.
I realize this reaction is probably because they are concerned about pissing off the RIAA or they are planning on introducing a similiar product. Even if they offered a similiar product, you know they would add some fair use limiting DRM feature that would make the product less useful than this independantly developed application. I think one other thing is that the existance of TiVo like features limits the needs for consumers to use any future Audio or Video on Demand service (that would bring in more fees). I know with my ReplayTV, I always have tons of things to watch so I have no need to use the VOD services of my cable company.
In any case, I hope that someone at XM jumped the gun on this and we will hopefully see a press release that clears up this mess.